The Spring housing market is proving to be more resilient than expected, with prices showing no signs of cooling down and competition remaining fierce. Despite the rise in mortgage rates, which typically dampens both prices and demand, the current market conditions are defying this trend. The scarcity of homes for sale is a key factor in keeping prices elevated, with many existing homeowners unable to afford moving up due to the high costs involved.
According to CoreLogic data, home prices registered a 5.5% increase in February compared to the same month the previous year. Although this annual comparison is slightly shrinking, the price gain from January to February was nearly double the average for that time of year. This suggests that the Spring housing market started off strong, despite the higher interest rates that should have slowed down activity.
Contrary to expectations, sales of newly built homes saw a nearly 6% increase in February year over year. However, pending sales of existing homes, based on signed contracts, experienced a 7% decline during the same period. The primary issue in today’s existing home market is the limited supply of homes available for sale. While there are more new listings this Spring compared to the previous year, the overall supply remains 40% lower than pre-pandemic levels.
Many current homeowners are reluctant to put their homes on the market due to the high costs associated with moving up. Data from ICE Mortgage Technology shows that upgrading to a home that is 25% more expensive could result in a 132% increase in the average homeowner’s monthly payment. This represents a significant change from previous years when upgrading to a more expensive home would only marginally increase the monthly payment.
The impact of rising mortgage rates and housing prices varies across different markets. For example, moving up to a more expensive home in Buffalo, New York, would result in a $604 increase in monthly payments (an increase of 108%), while the same move in San Jose, California, would lead to a $4,517 increase (an increase of 161%). These regional disparities highlight the challenges faced by homeowners in high-cost areas.
Andy Walden, ICE’s vice president of enterprise research, notes that lower interest rates would help facilitate more moves and make housing transactions more feasible. However, the persistent mismatch between supply and demand continues to put pressure on both inventory levels and affordability. Until this fundamental issue is addressed, the housing market will remain constrained by limited supply and high demand.
Walden suggests that a reduction in mortgage rates could make moving up to a more expensive home more attainable for many homeowners. For instance, if rates fell to 6%, the average monthly payment increase for trading up to a 25% more expensive home would ease from 103% to 88%. While this represents a modest improvement, it could incentivize individuals with a strong desire to upgrade their housing situation.
The current housing market faces challenges brought about by high home prices and mortgage rates. A recent report from Zillow indicates that the U.S. now boasts a record-high 550 “million-dollar” cities, where the typical home is valued at $1 million or more. This represents a significant increase from previous years, reflecting the ongoing trend of rising home values in many areas.
Leave a Reply